Why We Can’t Risk Having A Leader With A Drinking Problem
Leadership holds a place of immense importance in Scripture, especially among the people of God. Leaders are called to guide, protect, and serve as examples of holiness and integrity. However, when leaders struggle with vices like excessive drinking, their ability to fulfill these roles is compromised, and the consequences can ripple through the community. The Bible is clear: a leader must possess self-control and live above reproach, for their actions shape the spiritual and moral direction of those they lead.
This article delves into why we cannot afford to have leaders who struggle with a drinking problem and what Scripture teaches us about the characteristics of godly leadership.
---
Leadership: A Sacred Responsibility
In the Torah, leadership is portrayed as a sacred duty. Leaders were to stand as mediators between God and His people, ensuring that the community adhered to His commandments. This high calling demanded a life of discipline and focus.
When Moses gave instructions to appoint leaders in Israel, he emphasized their integrity:
"Provide for yourselves distinguished men, who are wise, understanding, and experienced, from your tribes, and I will appoint them as your leaders" (Deuteronomy 1:13).
A leader with a drinking problem risks failing in these areas. Alcohol impairs judgment, clouds understanding, and undermines wisdom—all of which are essential qualities for godly leadership.
---
The Biblical Warning Against Drunkenness
The Bible consistently warns about the dangers of alcohol, especially for those in positions of leadership. Proverbs 31:4-5 is particularly direct:
"It is not for kings, O Lemuel, not for kings to drink wine, nor for rulers to desire strong drink, lest they drink and forget what has been decreed, and pervert the rights of all the afflicted."
Leaders are expected to maintain clarity of mind and sound judgment to execute justice and uphold righteousness. Alcohol diminishes these abilities, making it easy for leaders to abuse their power or neglect their responsibilities.
The Nazirites, who were set apart for holy service, were forbidden to consume wine or strong drink (Numbers 6:3). This prohibition underscored the importance of maintaining a pure and undistracted connection with God. If leaders today are to guide the community in holiness, they must similarly avoid anything that compromises their spiritual clarity.
---
The Ripple Effect of a Leader’s Drinking Problem
A leader’s drinking problem does not just affect them—it impacts the entire community. When leaders falter, their followers are often left disillusioned, hurt, or led astray.
1. Eroding Trust:
Trust is the foundation of leadership. A leader struggling with alcohol may display erratic behavior, make poor decisions, or fail to uphold their commitments. Over time, this erodes the trust of the people they are meant to serve.
2. Setting a Poor Example:
Leaders are role models. When a leader indulges in excessive drinking, they send a message that this behavior is acceptable, potentially encouraging others to follow suit. Hosea 4:9 warns, “And it shall be, like people, like priest.” The conduct of leaders directly influences the behavior of those they lead.
3. Spiritual Consequences:
A leader’s spiritual walk is critical to their ability to lead effectively. Drinking excessively can dull their sensitivity to God’s voice and weaken their connection to Him. This spiritual disconnection not only affects the leader but also hinders their ability to guide others into deeper relationship with God.
---
God’s Standard for Leaders
God’s Word sets high standards for those in leadership. Leaders are called to embody self-control, humility, and a heart wholly devoted to God. Isaiah 56:10-12 provides a stark warning about the dangers of self-indulgent leaders:
"His watchmen are blind, all of them unaware; they are all dumb dogs that cannot bark; they lie sprawling, they love to drowse. And the dogs are greedy, they never know satiety. Such are the shepherds who cannot understand; they all turn to their own way, every last one seeks his own advantage. 'Come, I will take wine; let us swill liquor, and tomorrow will be just the same!'"
This passage describes leaders consumed by their own desires rather than the welfare of their people. Leaders with drinking problems are at risk of becoming like these “shepherds who cannot understand,” prioritizing their own cravings over their sacred responsibilities.
---
Historical Examples of Leadership Failures
The Bible gives us examples of leaders whose indulgence in alcohol led to disastrous outcomes:
1. Noah:
After the flood, Noah planted a vineyard, drank of its wine, and became drunk, leading to shameful consequences (Genesis 9:20-21). While Noah was a righteous man, this incident highlights the potential dangers of alcohol, even for those deeply committed to God.
2. Nadab and Abihu:
The sons of Aaron offered unauthorized fire before the LORD and were consumed by divine fire (Leviticus 10:1-2). While the text does not explicitly state that alcohol was involved, God’s subsequent command forbidding priests to drink wine before entering the Tent of Meeting (Leviticus 10:9) suggests that their judgment may have been impaired by intoxication.
These examples remind us that even a momentary lapse in judgment caused by alcohol can lead to significant consequences.
---
The Call for Sobriety in Leadership
For leaders to fulfill their calling, they must maintain a life of sobriety—both physically and spiritually. Sobriety allows leaders to remain vigilant, discerning, and fully reliant on God.
Proverbs 20:1 declares:
"Wine is a mocker, strong drink a brawler, and whoever is led astray by it is not wise."
Wisdom and self-control are indispensable qualities for leaders. A leader who allows alcohol to control them demonstrates a lack of discipline and wisdom, making them unfit to guide others.
---
Choosing Godly Leaders
As Messianic Jews, it is our responsibility to seek and support leaders who align with God’s standards. Leaders should exemplify lives of holiness, integrity, and self-control, serving as beacons of light in a world filled with darkness.
Psalm 101:6 captures the heart of this pursuit:
"My eyes are upon the faithful of the land, that they may dwell with me; he who walks in a way of integrity, he shall minister to me."
When selecting leaders, we must prioritize their spiritual maturity and commitment to God’s Word over charisma or worldly qualifications. A leader without self-control, especially in matters of alcohol, risks leading the community away from the path of righteousness.
---
Conclusion: A Call to Accountability
The danger of having a leader with a drinking problem cannot be overstated. Such a leader risks not only their own downfall but also the spiritual and moral decline of those they lead. As a community, we must hold our leaders accountable, praying for them and encouraging them to pursue lives of holiness and discipline.
Let us heed the words of Joshua 1:7:
"Only be very strong and resolute to observe faithfully all the Teaching that My servant Moses enjoined upon you. Do not deviate from it to the right or to the left, that you may be successful wherever you go."
May our leaders remain steadfast in their commitment to God’s Word, leading us with wisdom, clarity, and unwavering faithfulness. And may we, as a community, continue to seek the guidance of the One True Shepherd, who leads us beside still waters and restores our souls.